One Quarter Of Meat Substitutes Have Insufficient Protein – Safefood

A SafeFood Ireland report on vegetarian meat substitutes found that 28% or just over one-quarter of the 354 meat substitute products tested did not contain either high amounts of protein or could be considered an alternative source of protein. As a result of these findings, Safefood has stated that "consumers need to be aware of this if relying on these foods as a protein source." This statistic was widely reported in various Irish News publications. A less reported finding from the same report was the 49%, or almost half of the products examined are considered a high protein source (where the percentage of energy from protein is 20% or more), which will be detailed along with other findings below.


The report examined "ready to eat" vegetarian and vegan/ plant-based products available in Ireland between March & May 2020. The report examined a wide range of meat substitutes, from falafel to meat-style burgers, bean burgers, sausage rolls, spinach bites, nuggets, and fish substitutes. It should be noted at this point that the range of products cover both the highly processed meat alternatives (meat style burgers, fish replacements, etc are all highly processed, industrial-grade food) to those which are less processed or closed to nature (bean burgers, spinach bites, falafel etc are made using actual plants i.e. beans, spinach, chickpeas etc.


Shifting The Focus Away From Protein

While the media coverage of the Safefood report focused on the minority of products that did not contain adequate protein levels to be considered a meat alternative, there were several other key nutritional findings that paint plant-based substitutes to meat in a more positive light. Table 5 (below) taken from the report, show the comparison of plant based meat replacements to actual meat in the areas of carbohydrates, calories, fat, fibre, and saturated fat:


The table below highlights that while 28% of plant based products did not contain adequate protein levels (72% did), actual meat is higher in calories, fat and saturated fat, while plant based products contain higher levels of carbohydrates and fibre, which aids digestion. It should be noted that the chicken and turkey burgers carbohydrate content is a white breadcrumb coating, which has been stripped of almost all of their fibre and nutrient content.


Key Take Away: Educate Yourself

The SafeFood report itself was, upon reading, balanced and did not appear to demonise meat substitutes or alternatives. However, the media focus on the minority products which did not contain adequate levels of protein may alter consumers perceptions of the product category as a whole. Here at Plant-Based Ireland, we advocate for the consumption of a diet consisting of whole plants in their natural form, while keeping processed food intake to a minimum.


Plant-based meat substitutes are a relatively new product category, but should not be the foundation on which one builds a healthy, sustainable plant-based diet upon. Consumers should be constantly educating themselves on their eating, and always remember that the health benefits of a plant-based diet are found in the nutrient content of the plants themselves, not in the absence of animal products.

Ashton Kutcher Invests in Lab-Grown Meat Company

In celebrity news, Ashton Kutcher has invested in cultured meat company MeaTech 3D. MeaTech is an Israeli company, which aims to provide a more sustainable ‘meat’ solution, by developing an industrial cultured meat production process, usi...

Documentary Eating Our Way to Extinction Promotes Plant Based Eating For The Environment

“Eating Our Way to Extinction” is a timely documentary with an urgent message and backed by a host of Hollywood names. Narrated by Kate Winslet and supported by Leonardo Di Caprio, this documentary is much more than a fleeting video messa...

Dr. Oetker Launches First Ristorante Vegan Pizza

One of the nation’s top frozen pizza brands, Dr. Oetker’s Ristorante, carried out its own research, surveying 600 Irish people and found that over 50% of respondents, aged 18-55, would describe their diets as Flexitarian, while 88% would consider...

A Guide to Milk Alternatives

A Guide to Milk Alternatives Introduction We now live in a world full of alternative food and drink options created to cater for all kinds of diets and lifestyles. These days it’s common to find a range of dairy alternatives in a dedicated aisle at...

A Guide to CBD Oil for Plant Based Eaters & Vegans in Ireland

This article will guide any person following a plant based or vegan diet through the CBD market place. We will look at the ingredients of CBD oils and other CBD products so that you can be sure no animal derivatives are present in the CBD option you ...

Harvest Day Expands To Offer Nationwide Deliveries of Fresh Organically & Naturally Grown 100% Irish Produce

Harvest Day is now offering weekly and fortnightly deliveries of freshly picked organic 100% Irish produce direct to customers’ doors

EU Amendment 171 May Censor Plant Based Dairy Phrases & Packaging

The EU is currently debating draft legislation that, if passed, would have a dramatic impact on the labeling, marketing, and sales of plant-based foods across the continent

Nibbed Cacao: High Quality, Hand-Made Plant Based Chocolate

A brand new Irish Cacao Start-up, Nibbed Cacao, is bringing ethical, high quality, delicious cacao products to Irish consumers with their range of Teas, Chocolate Bark, Nibbles and more available from their website & stores nationwide

What Fruit & Vegetables Are In Season In Ireland? The EUFIC Have Launched An Online Guide

The European Food Information Council (EUFIC) launched Europe’s very first interactive fruit and vegetables seasonality map today. It provides accurate and reliable information that helps navigate in an easy way towards healthier and more sustainab...

French Plant Based Restaurant ONA Awarded Michelin Star

ONA Becomes The First Plant-Based Restaurant In France To Recieve The Prestigious Award   Plant-Based Restaurant ONA, which stands for Origine Non-Animale (or Animal-Free Origin), was awarded a Michelin Star on the 18th of January, making it the...